The cherry head tortoise and the common red-footed tortoise are often confused with each other.
Fundamental to their appeal are their colorful appearances and small sizes. No matter which you choose, you’ll own an eye-catching tortoise that doesn’t take up much space.
While these tortoises share similarities, they differ in appearance, temperament, price, lifespan, and activity levels. These factors determine how easy your preferred tortoise will be to care for in captivity.
Cherry Head Tortoise Basic Information
Cherry-head tortoises are the red-headed variant of the common red-foot tortoises (chelonoidis carbonarius). They’re also called eastern red-foots or Brazilian red-footed tortoises because they’re indigenous to Brazil’s eastern and southeastern regions. They can also be found in Bolivia, Panama, and Paraguay, albeit in smaller numbers.
As the name suggests, cherry heads have bright-colored heads, with colors ranging from brick red to cherry red. Often, the legs will be covered in the same reddish hue. From afar, they look identical to their close cousins, the yellow-footed cherry head tortoises. However, the latter is much bigger.
Not all cherry head tortoises have red heads, as many brandish orange, dark yellow, and pinkish hues. However, their heads are always brighter than ordinary red foots.
Cherry red tortoises aren’t bred for their color like other animals, as they’re a distinct sub-species, and their colors are genetically transmitted. Still, their exact origins remain a mystery, and the question of how they attained their head coloration is unknown.
It’s unclear whether diet plays a role in coloration. Still, we know that the reddish hue is only present in tortoises from the southern and eastern parts of the Amazon basin.
Red-Footed Tortoise Basic Information
The ordinary red-foots (also known as northern red-foots, red-leg, or savanna tortoises) are the main sub-group of the chelonoidis carbonarius species.
They mostly inhabit the areas north of the Amazon basin, including:
- Northern Brazil
- Venezuela
- Guyana
- Panama
- Colombia
Unlike the cherry heads, red-foots are also found in other regions, such as Europe.
According to Organisms, Diversity, and Evolution, red-footed tortoises aren’t a monolith because they’re spread across such a massive geographical area. Instead, they have up to 5 genotypes.
However, the differences between these genotypes aren’t significant enough, with the plastron colors being the only noticeable differences. The head and limb colors are mostly the same, ranging from pale yellow to orange. Some tortoises have a reddish hue, but this is rare.
In recent years, breeders have started crossing northern red-foots with cherry heads. These hybrids have a more pronounced orange color and are smaller than red-foots.
Differences Between Cherry Head and Red-Foot Tortoises
When choosing between tortoises, a difference in origins, genetics, and basic coloration is important. However, you’ll need more than that before committing for 2-3 decades.
Here are the details that set these tortoises apart, so you can tell which is right for you:
Appearance
Despite their color differences, minor physical characteristics set these tortoises apart. From their nasal shape to their growth rate, here are where the variants separate from each other:
Head Color
Cherry heads have darker shades of red or orange colors on their heads and limbs. That’s paired with more elaborate color patterns on their heads.
Red-foot tortoises mostly have pale yellow scales on their heads and necks. Only some have a touch of orange or near-black hues in these areas.
Plastron Color
Cherry heads have darker plastrons, which are often arranged in symmetrical patterns. In between the patterns are thick, whitish, or light-gray lines.
In red-foots, the plastrons have pale yellow bases, but some variants have darker markings between the scutes. Others have light gray plastrons, with dark marks rare among the sub-species.
Size
Cherry heads are smaller on average, with the normal adults growing up to 10 inches for males and 9 inches for females. However, it’s not uncommon to find giant cherry heads, which are larger than 14 inches, which is more likely in wild tortoises than captive tortoises.
Red-foots average from 12-14 inches and often grow to 15-16 inches if well cared for. As with cherry heads, the males will be larger on average than females.
Nasal Shape
Cherry reds have a more pronounced nasal structure, which also appears brightly colored compared to other parts of their heads. Meanwhile, the noses of red-foots are less bulbous and darker in color.
Scale Patterns
The leg scales of cherry heads normally brandish the same colors as the head. In contrast, red-foots come in various colors, with red and orange being the dominant hues. Furthermore, red-foots possess more black scales on their legs than the more colorful cherry heads.
Growth Rate
Due to their smaller growth potential, cherry heads reach maturity faster than red-foots, growing up within 4-6 years. However, red-foots take more time to reach their mature size.
Levels of Activity
Red-foots have lots of energy, which they spend exploring their tanks, digging, and foraging.
In comparison, cherry heads are less active, especially in cooler temperatures, and will spend entire days in their burrows.
Price
Cherry heads cost $400-$1500 at credible pet shops. Ordinary red-foots are far cheaper, fetching as little as $150, with prices rarely exceeding $600.
The steep prices for cherry heads can be explained by how most people perceive unusual color variations, as they’re considered signs of “exoticness” and higher desirability. Therefore, people are prepared to pay high amounts to lay claim to a cherry head.
Additionally, many breeders tag their cherry heads as “dwarfs” to take advantage of the universal preference for smaller pets.
The fact that cherry heads are naturally smaller than red-foots works in their favor. Many buyers mistakenly believe that they’re merely the dwarf variety of red-foots.
Lifespan
In captivity, red-foots can live for an average of 50 years if kept in the right conditions and fed the right diets. The same holds for cherry heads, as they’re a subspecies of the same group.
How Are Cherry Head and Red-Footed Tortoises Alike?
Aside from their distinct differences, cherry heads and red-foots have much in common. Here are traits you don’t have to worry about losing when you choose one over the other:
Intelligence
Red-foots and cherry heads are both considered intelligent species.
According to Behavioural Processes, they both demonstrate proficiency in using touchscreens and understanding the concept of spatial discrimination.
This shows that they can be trained to perform tricks, work through mazes, and follow basic commands.
Risk-Taking
According to Applied Animal Behaviour Science, cherry-head and red-footed tortoises take risks more frequently than their yellow-footed cousins. So, they’re likely to scale cage walls, jump off high decorations, or squirm out of your hands.
Be sure there are no climbable walls or precarious rocks in your tortoise cage because this will prevent attempts to escape and explore the world beyond their enclosure.
Temperament
Red-footed tortoises are normally shy, calm, and friendly; the same applies to cherry heads. Some are so docile that they’ll constantly hide to avoid contact with humans or other pets.
Male torts, across all variants, are antagonistic and will fight each other, mostly over females. For this reason, keeping several males in the same enclosure isn’t recommended.
Diet
For both kinds of tortoise, a large portion of their diet is composed of fruits, flowers, leaves, fungi, and cacti, and the latter is especially popular with cherry heads.
These tortoises are omnivorous, so they’ll need animal proteins occasionally. Herpetological Review shows that tortoises often scavenge the carcasses of dead animals in jungles.
